Tuesday, August 10, 2010

The perfect pen for tefillin repairs

I just came across a blog of a sofer's story about his experience with a new pen for correcting tefillin (and mezuzahs, etc.). I've been checking tefillin for over 20 years and many years ago I experimented with every available techincal pen or rapidograph. I tried Reform, Kohinoor and a few others. No matter if I used the original ink that came with them or sofer's ink (diyo) I had tremendous agmas nefesh. They would get blocked and require a thorough cleaning or air bubbles would form causing ink to flow out, making it impossible to use. I knew an experienced sofer had been using the Rotring brand technical pen and I finally broke down and picked one up (the most expensive) and is was amazing. I finally had to replace it when it fell on the floor and the tip bent. Since then I will only use Rotring and own a number of them and love them! They come with various sides tips. For tefillin and mezuzah the 01, 02 and 03mm tips are perfect as you can get into any spot and precisely place the ink where you want it. I'm surprised the sofer of this blog has just heard about the Rotring, since I thought it has been well known for years that it is by far the best pen.
Now surely some of you are wondering why I am using a pen and not a quill. While a quill should preferably be used for writing, it is accepted that a pen may be used for repairs. It is very difficult and risky to do touch ups with a quill.
The main issue is whether one may use the ink that comes with it or should sofer's ink be used. Some of the technical pen inks have been lab tested and found to not contain problematic ingredients. The main problem is if the black coloring comes from burnt bones from a non kosher animal species. If the black is from a synthetic source or from burnt bones of a kosher animal species then the ink is ok but then there is the question as to whether ink made from traditional ingredients such as sofer's ink, should be used. Some sofrim use sofer's ink and some use the regular ink.
While the techincal pen ink flows well from the Rotring, it is not a simple matter with sofer's ink. The sofer's ink that most use in the technical pen is Hadar #17 as it is very liquidy. The problem is that often you need to go over it a few times for it to be black. Also, it flows better from the 03mm tip and for very tight spots, the 03 can be a little tough. I've recently been told about a newer ink which is supposed to work very well with the Rotring and I plan to check it out.
The other sofer mentioned keeping a little moisture on the pen tip after each use and I agree that it is very helpful.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

Whats the wrap on the all black tefillin straps?

For a more thorough treatment of the laws of retzuos (tefillin straps) read "Are your tefillin straps kosher?".

Many of you have heard about all black tefillin straps or black on both sides. First let me clarify what they are. Before the hides are cut into straps they are dipped into a vat of kosher black dye and are kept in the vat until the dye has soaked totally through the hides. Once dry the top surface is painted, just like regular tefillin straps. Finally, the hides are cut into straps and the top, bottom and (in)sides of the straps are all black.
What are the advantages of all black tefillin straps?
1) While we don't pasken like this opionion, the Rambam and some kabbalistic opinions are that the straps should also be black on the back side.
2) The keses Hasofer (author of the kitzur shulchan aruch) says that the sides of the straps should be black. I was also shown a source that says that this is also the opinion of the Vilna Gaon.
If any part of the tefillin strap is visibly not black in is minimally kosher bedieved (not preferable standard) and can even make the tefillin passul, invalid. With all black straps you never have to be concerned since once the upper layer of paint wears off, the leather is still black beneath!
While some question whether these straps should be used with the claim that if they are okay and have the above advantages then why weren't they made many years ago. Nevertheless, as far as I'm aware, there is no halachic issue with them and a number of major rabbis, including the Badatz Edah Hachareidis, give their approval. Taking into account that a clear majority tefillin with regular tefillin straps are bedieved or passul due to missing/worn off paint then in my humble opinion, these tefillin straps are a lifesaver. For the few that are very careful and know how to properly check their tefillin on a regular basis they can continue wearing regular tefillin straps but for the rest of us who, for whatever reason, know that we are not going to check our tefillin straps properly and often enough, the all black tefillin straps are most worthwhile. The fact is that the difference in price between regular and all black tefillin straps, from the same maker is only around $10. In fact, at http://www.stam.net/, on our tefillin we automatically put on the all black straps, at no additional cost, unless the customer specifically requests standard tefillin straps.